Practice 04 · Ask before, Assure after
Two checks on the money: before it leaves, and after it has.
Pre-audit reviews payments above an agreed value before they are released. Transaction audit tests completed payments on the full population. Together they close the gap that approvals leave open.
Most controls over payments are approvals. An approval says someone signed. It does not say whether the rate matched the contract, whether the goods arrived, or whether the same invoice was paid twice. Transaction assurance checks the payment itself, before and after.
- A capex programme or a large contractor base where rates and measurements drive the bill.
- Duplicate or split payments found once, and nobody sure there are no more.
- Advances that never close, vendors created last week, payments just under approval limits.
- A promoter who signs the cheque but no longer sees the paperwork behind it.
Money that has left is expensive to recover and embarrassing to explain. Money stopped before release costs nothing. Without a check on the transaction, the control is only as good as the person who approved it.
- Pre-auditPayments above an agreed threshold reviewed before release: contract or order, receipt or measurement, rate, taxes and deductions, approval trail. A payment that does not hold up is put on hold with a written reason.
- Transaction auditCompleted payments tested on the full population: duplicates, rate and quantity deviations, split payments, payments to related or newly created vendors, advances that never closed. Recoverable amounts go on a list with the document that supports each one.
- FeedbackPatterns found after payment tighten the checks before the next one. Tests that keep finding issues move into Continuous Control Monitoring.
- Hold register: payments stopped, reason, resolution.
- Recoveries list, each item evidenced.
- Cycle exceptions note, two pages.
- Tightened pre-release checklist for the payments team.
Questions
Asked before the first call.
Will pre-audit slow down payments?
Only payments above the agreed threshold are reviewed, and the review runs inside the payment cycle. Most companies set the threshold so that under 5% of payments by count, and over 60% by value, pass through it.
What is the difference between pre-audit and concurrent audit?
Concurrent audit is a bank term for near-real-time checking of transactions. Pre-audit is narrower: a check on specific payments before release, against the documents that should support them.
Do you recover the money?
We identify it, evidence it and quantify it. Recovery is management’s action; our list is written so that the vendor conversation is short.
Is this an internal audit?
It can sit inside one. Many clients run transaction audit as a module of Governance & Controls Assurance and move the recurring tests into monitoring.
Related practices